← Best of the Best: all the guides
The best fluoride-free toothpastes
Boka Ela Mint wins for its mild flavor, strong reviewer track record and fluoride-free formula with nano-hydroxyapatite.
| Best overall | Best value | Cheapest that's still good | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Product | Boka Ela Mint Nano-Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste, 4 oz | Davids Hydroxi Whitening + Enamel Health Nano Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste, Peppermint, 4 oz | Tom’s of Maine Fluoride-Free Antiplaque & Whitening Toothpaste, Peppermint, 4.7 oz |
| Price | about $12 | about $11 | about $8 |
| Why | Dental Roundup’s 2026 comparison chose it as its editor’s pick, citing its mild mint flavor and large review base. Dr. Axe’s September 2026 review also reported an independent lab test of this exact flavor; the listed result was 32 ppb lead. | Dental Roundup lists Davids Hydroxi as its best value, around $10, and notes its aluminum tube and EWG-verified ingredients. It is a lower-cost single-tube way to try nano-hydroxyapatite. | Dr. Axe’s September 2026 comparison listed it at about $8, making it the lowest-priced pick here. Dental Roundup also included the formula in its recent comparison and noted its broad availability and long-standing user-review history. |
| Good to know | The hydroxyapatite concentration is not disclosed. | The reported lab results for related Davids pastes included lead and arsenic. | It does not contain hydroxyapatite. |
| See on Amazon → | See on Amazon → | See on Amazon → |
Dental Roundup’s 2026 comparison chose it as its editor’s pick, citing its mild mint flavor and large review base. Dr. Axe’s September 2026 review also reported an independent lab test of this exact flavor; the listed result was 32 ppb lead.
Good to know: The hydroxyapatite concentration is not disclosed.
See on AmazonDental Roundup lists Davids Hydroxi as its best value, around $10, and notes its aluminum tube and EWG-verified ingredients. It is a lower-cost single-tube way to try nano-hydroxyapatite.
Good to know: The reported lab results for related Davids pastes included lead and arsenic.
See on AmazonDr. Axe’s September 2026 comparison listed it at about $8, making it the lowest-priced pick here. Dental Roundup also included the formula in its recent comparison and noted its broad availability and long-standing user-review history.
Good to know: It does not contain hydroxyapatite.
See on AmazonDanilli may earn a small commission from Amazon when you buy through these buttons. The price is the same for you.
What matters
Dentists still recommend fluoride toothpaste to help prevent cavities; choosing fluoride-free is a personal choice. Compare ingredients, flavor, price per tube and whether the product is free of ingredients you prefer to avoid.
Who this is for
These picks are for U.S. adults who have decided to buy fluoride-free toothpaste this week. If you have a high risk of cavities or are choosing for a child, ask a dentist before switching.
The picks, one by one
Best overall: Boka Ela Mint Nano-Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste, 4 oz
Dental Roundup’s 2026 comparison chose it as its editor’s pick, citing its mild mint flavor and large review base. Dr. Axe’s September 2026 review also reported an independent lab test of this exact flavor; the listed result was 32 ppb lead. It contains nano-hydroxyapatite and is listed as free of fluoride, SLS and parabens. One important limitation: Boka does not disclose the hydroxyapatite percentage, and lab tests of ingredients are not a clinical test of cavity outcomes. The expert comparison cited clinical trials of 10% hydroxyapatite, but those trials did not test Boka’s product. Choose another option if you want a disclosed concentration or dislike mint.
Good to know: The hydroxyapatite concentration is not disclosed.
See on AmazonBest value: Davids Hydroxi Whitening + Enamel Health Nano Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste, Peppermint, 4 oz
Dental Roundup lists Davids Hydroxi as its best value, around $10, and notes its aluminum tube and EWG-verified ingredients. It is a lower-cost single-tube way to try nano-hydroxyapatite. The formula is fluoride-free and uses nano-hydroxyapatite and xylitol. The comparison describes the peppermint flavor as mild. Dr. Axe’s September 2026 review noted that this brand’s pastes had independent lab results reporting lead and arsenic; those reports covered a peppermint paste with the same ingredients and a separate orange-vanilla Hydroxi paste, not this exact peppermint Hydroxi tube. Skip it if those reported tests concern you.
Good to know: The reported lab results for related Davids pastes included lead and arsenic.
See on AmazonCheapest that's still good: Tom’s of Maine Fluoride-Free Antiplaque & Whitening Toothpaste, Peppermint, 4.7 oz
Dr. Axe’s September 2026 comparison listed it at about $8, making it the lowest-priced pick here. Dental Roundup also included the formula in its recent comparison and noted its broad availability and long-standing user-review history. It is fluoride-free and uses calcium carbonate and hydrated silica for cleaning and polishing. Unlike Boka and Davids, it does not contain hydroxyapatite. The comparison says Tom’s markets the formula as free of artificial flavors and colors, but ingredient listings may vary, so check the package if you avoid a specific ingredient. Choose another pick if nano-hydroxyapatite is important to you.
Good to know: It does not contain hydroxyapatite.
See on AmazonHow we chose
Recent comparison articles assessed ingredient lists, disclosed hydroxyapatite content, independent lab reports where available, prices and user-review patterns. Those comparisons did not report a standardized, hands-on brushing test or a single test period across all three products. Danilli read the reviews and tests listed below and compared current prices; it does not take money from brands to pick a product.
Sources
- Dental Roundup, Best Fluoride-Free Toothpaste of 2026
- Dr. Axe, The Best Fluoride-Free Toothpastes of 2026
- American Dental Association, Toothpastes
- Dental Roundup, Amazon listing for Boka Ela Mint
- Dental Roundup, Amazon listing for Davids Hydroxi
- Dental Roundup, Amazon listing for Tom’s of Maine Fluoride-Free Antiplaque & Whi
Not sure which one is for you?
Ask Danilli anything about these, free. Tell it what you need and your budget and it says which one fits you.
Written with Danilli's AI from the sources above and refreshed about once a month; prices change, check Amazon for today's price. Danilli may earn a small commission from Amazon when you buy through these buttons. The price is the same for you.