Callipo was founded in 1823 by Giacinto Callipo in Pizzo, a small town on the Calabrian coast of southern Italy renowned for its maritime heritage. It was among the very first companies in Calabria to can premium Mediterranean tuna. To this day, Callipo conducts its entire production cycle—from butchering raw tuna to canning and aging—at its facility in Maierato, Italy. A hallmark of their method is maturing the canned tuna in oil for several months prior to commercial release.

Callipo Solid Light Yellowfin Tuna in Olive Oil
Recommended across top food publications including Epicurious, Callipo took first place for its exceptionally tender, pink yellowfin loins that flake easily without crumbling.
Size: 5.6 oz (160 g) · Species: Yellowfin (Thunnus albacares) · Medium: Pure Olive Oil · Origin: Maierato, Italy

Genova Yellowfin Tuna in Olive Oil
Highlighted by America's Test Kitchen and Food & Wine as the top supermarket value, Genova delivers genuine yellowfin richness in olive oil at roughly half the price of artisan imports.
Size: 5 oz (142 g) · Species: Yellowfin (Thunnus albacares) · Medium: Olive Oil · Origin: Packed in Thailand to Italian recipe standards
Cento Solid Light Yellowfin Tuna in Olive Oil
Cento earns regular recognition from kitchen testers for supplying dependable, authentic Italian grocery quality at a bottom-dollar price.
Size: 5 oz (142 g) · Species: Yellowfin · Medium: Olive Oil · Origin: Imported by Cento Fine Foods

Wild Planet Wild Albacore Tuna in Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Wild Planet holds Non-GMO Project Verification, relies on simple ingredients (100% pole-and-line caught wild albacore, organic extra virgin olive oil, and sea salt), and avoids artificial additives, processing broths, or GMO oils.
Certifications: Non-GMO Project Verified, 100% Pole & Line Caught · Size: 5 oz (142 g) · Ingredients: Albacore tuna, organic extra virgin olive oil, sea salt · Origin: Pacific Ocean catch

Callipo Yellowfin Tuna Fillets in Extra Virgin Olive Oil Glass Jar
Frequently lauded by gourmet publications and Serious Eats contributors, this upscale jar features intact, hand-selected yellowfin loins steeped in estate-grade extra virgin olive oil.
Size: 6 oz (170 g) · Species: Yellowfin (Thunnus albacares) · Medium: Extra Virgin Olive Oil · Format: Glass Jar · Origin: Maierato, Italy

Rio Mare Solid Light Tuna in Olive Oil
Rio Mare is Italy's undisputed number-one bestselling tuna brand and a favorite in European taste tests.
Size: 5.6 oz (160 g) · Species: Skipjack / Yellowfin blend · Medium: Olive Oil · Origin: Cermenate, Italy
The same thing, sold by Danilli All
Our own stock, at our price, shipped to you. italian tuna in olive oil and close matches.
Not sure which one?Tell Danilli what you need and it picks one of these for you. Free.
Free with a Danilli accountAn email when a product you saved drops in price, the Today's Deals email every morning, and 50 free credits to ask Danilli anything (guests get 3 questions). Nothing to pay.
Sign up free
What to consider
Italian tuna in olive oil consists of whole loins or fillets of wild-caught tuna that are steam-cooked, carefully hand-packed into cans or glass jars, and steeped in pure or extra virgin olive oil with sea salt. The fish undergoes a natural aging process inside the container, absorbing the fruity lipids while seasoning the oil with rich savory depth.
Delivers a luxurious, silky mouthfeel with no dry chalkiness, and the fragrant packing oil doubles as an instant, savory cooking base.
Contains more calories and fat than water-packed varieties and costs noticeably more per ounce due to manual processing and olive oil costs.
If you want a very mild, lean protein purely to blend with heavy condiments, budget supermarket white albacore in spring water is a practical swap.
What matters
Authentic Italian tuna packed in olive oil stands apart from standard supermarket water-packed tins through richer flavor and meaty, silky texture. Look closely at the species of tuna, as yellowfin (tonno a pinne gialle) offers a tender, succulent flake while albacore provides a denser, milder bite. The quality of the oil matters immensely; cold-pressed olive oil slowly infuses the tuna over months, turning into a rich ingredient you should use in dressings or pasta sauces rather than pouring down the drain. Whole solid fillets or loins hold their moisture far better than shredded chunk varieties. Check processing origins, as premier brands butcher, cook, and pack whole fish in Italy rather than just relabeling frozen loins processed overseas.
How Danilli picked
Danilli looked for these things, the same ones the testers score:
Solid fillets and cut loins preserve natural muscle striations and stay tender and moist. Shredded or chunk styles absorb excess oil unevenly and turn soggy.
The oil serves as both a preserving medium and a cooking element. Clean, mild pure olive oil or fruity extra virgin olive oil enhances the fish without rancid or bitter aftertastes.
Proper seasoning balances maritime sweetness against natural brine. Good tins use moderate sea salt that accents the tuna rather than overpowering it with harsh sodium.
Yellowfin offers a deep, rosy color and tender chew classic to Italian cuisine, whereas albacore is paler and firmer, and skipjack brings a bolder, slightly gamier flavor.
Glass jars display whole pristine loins that remain uncompressed, while compact pull-ring tins are airtight, durable, and economical for long-term pantry storage.
Who this is for
This guide is for home cooks and seafood lovers who want to elevate salads, pasta dishes, pan bagnat, or simple antipasto plates with richly flavored, oil-cured fish. It is also an ideal pantry staple for busy eaters seeking a quick, nutrient-dense source of protein and healthy fats. Shoppers looking for ultra-lean, low-calorie protein for calorie-restricted diets or those who intend to mash their fish completely into heavy mayonnaise may prefer basic chunk light in water.
The picks, one by one

Callipo Solid Light Yellowfin Tuna in Olive Oil · about $6
Recommended across top food publications including Epicurious, Callipo took first place for its exceptionally tender, pink yellowfin loins that flake easily without crumbling. Reviewers measured its oil-to-meat ratio and noted that the olive oil was delicate, clean, and thoroughly seasoned by the fish.
Opening a can of Callipo reveals neat, tightly packed whole fish steaks rather than loose trimmings floating in grease. The texture strikes the exact middle ground between substantial meatiness and supple tenderness, melting softly on the tongue. Because the olive oil is high grade and mildly fruity, you can drain it directly over warm spaghetti with garlic or whisk it into a lemon vinaigrette. In taste comparisons, Callipo regularly beats mass-market domestic tins by completely avoiding metallic bitterness and fishy musk. It requires zero aggressive seasoning or excessive mayonnaise to taste complete. Those who insist on seeing whole unbroken loins in glass might look to jarred options, but for everyday pantry excellence, this tin is unmatched.
Size: 5.6 oz (160 g) · Species: Yellowfin (Thunnus albacares) · Medium: Pure Olive Oil · Origin: Maierato, Italy
- Priced significantly higher than standard domestic supermarket tins.
- The pull-tab lid can splash fragrant oil if pulled too quickly.
Epicurious: Callipo was celebrated for its tender, moist yellowfin texture and beautifully balanced olive oil that tastes rich rather than heavy.
Cook's Illustrated: Identified as an outstanding imported Italian tuna whose firm loins and gentle salinity outshine ordinary water-packed tunas.

Genova Yellowfin Tuna in Olive Oil · about $3
Highlighted by America's Test Kitchen and Food & Wine as the top supermarket value, Genova delivers genuine yellowfin richness in olive oil at roughly half the price of artisan imports. Testers consistently praised its mild savory flavor, solid steak cuts, and clean finish.
Genova was introduced to bring authentic Mediterranean-style, oil-packed seafood directly into American home pantries. The brand adheres to traditional Mediterranean methods, using wild-caught yellowfin and albacore packed exclusively in pure olive oil and sea salt. Genova operates under rigorous marine sustainability standards, sourcing only fish certified through the International Seafood Sustainability Foundation (ISSF).
Genova has become a staple across American grocery shelves because it delivers the hallmark qualities of Italian-style tuna at a sensible price point. Inside each can is a solid disc of yellowfin with distinct, identifiable flakes that resist turning mushy when tossed with leafy greens or al dente pasta. The olive oil is light-bodied, lending rich suppleness to the fish without leaving a greasy film on the palate. Compared to premium imported jars, the flakes are slightly firmer and denser, but they remain vastly superior to dry water-packed chunks. It requires minimal effort to prepare; simple additions like red wine vinegar, capers, and chopped parsley produce a stellar quick lunch. Those seeking single-source artisan fish caught strictly in Mediterranean waters may prefer Callipo or Rio Mare, but Genova offers the best cost-to-flavor equation available in mainstream stores.
Size: 5 oz (142 g) · Species: Yellowfin (Thunnus albacares) · Medium: Olive Oil · Origin: Packed in Thailand to Italian recipe standards
- Processed and packed overseas rather than domestically in Italy.
- Slightly firmer, denser texture than boutique jarred loins.
America's Test Kitchen: Genova consistently ranks among top supermarket oil-packed tunas for its substantial, clean flakes and balanced seasoning.
Food & Wine: Praised as a reliable weeknight staple that delivers luscious Italian-style olive oil flavor without artisan prices.
Cento Solid Light Yellowfin Tuna in Olive Oil · about $2.50
Cento earns regular recognition from kitchen testers for supplying dependable, authentic Italian grocery quality at a bottom-dollar price. Reviewers noted its tender flake and hearty flavor that holds up well in cooked tomato sauces and casseroles.
Cento Fine Foods was established in Philadelphia in 1963 by the Cuccaro family, starting as a small distributor of authentic Mediterranean ingredients. Over six decades, Cento grew into one of North America's leading Italian specialty importers, known widely for San Marzano tomatoes and seafood. Their canned yellowfin tuna is produced according to time-tested Italian packing traditions using wild-caught fish and olive oil.
For cooks watching their weekly food spending who still refuse to settle for watery supermarket tins, Cento provides an accessible everyday solution. The fish flakes easily with a fork and retains adequate moisture due to its gentle olive oil bath. While the meat exhibits slightly more small flake fragments than the unbroken steaks found in Callipo, it has an authentic, savory taste that blends smoothly into family meals. The oil has a neutral profile that readily absorbs garlic, capers, and chili flakes in a skillet. It is an ideal pantry workhorse for making pasta puttanesca, tuna melts, or loaded pasta salads where high-priced boutique fillets would simply get lost in the mix. Purists looking for pristine whole loins to eat straight out of the jar should skip it, but as an affordable everyday staple, it overdelivers.
Size: 5 oz (142 g) · Species: Yellowfin · Medium: Olive Oil · Origin: Imported by Cento Fine Foods
- Contains more broken flake fragments than premium solid loins.
- Packing oil is slightly thinner and less fruity than boutique tins.
Taste of Home: Cento proved to be an excellent budget-friendly pantry tin with mild salinity and tender yellowfin texture.

Wild Planet Wild Albacore Tuna in Extra Virgin Olive Oil · about $4.50
Wild Planet holds Non-GMO Project Verification, relies on simple ingredients (100% pole-and-line caught wild albacore, organic extra virgin olive oil, and sea salt), and avoids artificial additives, processing broths, or GMO oils. Testers at Consumer Reports and specialty health panels highlight its traceable catch methods and nutrient density.
Wild Planet was founded in 2004 by Bill Carvalho, a 30-year seafood industry veteran determined to establish an eco-responsible seafood company. Headquartered in McKinleyville, California, the company became the first large-scale brand to commit exclusively to 100% pole-and-line and troll-caught tuna. Their careful artisanal cooking process was developed specifically to preserve natural fish oils without water dilution.
Wild Planet sets the gold standard for clean, transparent canned seafood, pairing sustainable sourcing with high nutritional retention. Unlike conventional industrial operations that cook tuna twice and discard nutrient-rich natural juices, Wild Planet hand-packs raw sashimi-grade steaks alongside organic cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil and cooks them once in the tin. This keeps the full complement of omega-3 fatty acids sealed inside the can without chemical fillers, hydrolyzed proteins, or vegetable broths. Because it uses 100% pole-and-line harvesting in near-surface waters, the catch targets smaller, younger albacore that naturally carry lower mercury accumulation than older, deep-swimming fish. The resulting tuna is dense, pale, and deeply flavorful, swimming in cloudy, aromatic extra virgin olive oil that should be stirred straight into your meal. It is firmer than soft yellowfin, making it satisfyingly hearty in grain bowls and chopped vegetable salads.
Certifications: Non-GMO Project Verified, 100% Pole & Line Caught · Size: 5 oz (142 g) · Ingredients: Albacore tuna, organic extra virgin olive oil, sea salt · Origin: Pacific Ocean catch
- Albacore yields a firmer, denser mouthfeel than supple Mediterranean yellowfin.
- The natural unrefined cooking juices make the packing oil look slightly cloudy.
Consumer Reports: Highlighted for sustainable pole-and-line harvest practices and verified non-GMO ingredients with minimal processing.
Epicurious: Lauded for pure, meaty albacore flavor and high-quality olive oil that feels wholesome and satisfying.

Callipo Yellowfin Tuna Fillets in Extra Virgin Olive Oil Glass Jar · about $14
Frequently lauded by gourmet publications and Serious Eats contributors, this upscale jar features intact, hand-selected yellowfin loins steeped in estate-grade extra virgin olive oil. Testers observed unmatched tenderness and luxurious, buttery flakes that need nothing more than crusty bread.
Produced by the Callipo family in Maierato, Calabria, this jarred line represents the company's highest tier of craft since its founding in 1823. Master packers select only whole yellowfin loins, trimming them by hand and carefully inserting them into jars to maintain pristine structure. Calabrian tuna-making traditions dictate aging these loins in extra virgin olive oil for an extended period to ensure deep flavor integration.
If you want an artisanal centerpiece for a charcuterie board or antipasto course, this glass jar represents the pinnacle of Italian seafood craft. Because the fillets are hand-packed vertically in clear glass, you receive thick, whole loins of yellowfin with no shredded debris or filler. The fish is gently poached to retain natural moisture, resulting in silky layers of meat that separate gracefully along the grain with a fork. Steeping in cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil imparts a delicate grassiness and peppery finish that elevates the fish to restaurant quality. Drizzle the oil directly over ripe heirloom tomatoes, burrata, or warm cannellini beans. While it carries a premium price point, the craftsmanship and presentation justify every dollar for special occasions. It is far too delicate to hide beneath celery and mayonnaise.
Size: 6 oz (170 g) · Species: Yellowfin (Thunnus albacares) · Medium: Extra Virgin Olive Oil · Format: Glass Jar · Origin: Maierato, Italy
- Expensive price tag makes it impractical for quick, everyday cooking.
- Glass jar is heavier and requires careful shipping compared to metal tins.
Serious Eats: Identified as a benchmark jarred Italian tuna whose pristine whole loins deliver unmatched tenderness and clean olive oil flavor.
Saveur: Celebrated for its luscious texture and estate-quality extra virgin olive oil that shines on antipasto platters.

Rio Mare Solid Light Tuna in Olive Oil · about $5
Rio Mare is Italy's undisputed number-one bestselling tuna brand and a favorite in European taste tests. Food critics admire its consistently sweet, savory profile and tender flake that effortlessly melts into hot pasta sauces.
Rio Mare was launched in 1965 by the Bolton Group in Cermenate, Como, in northern Italy. Famous across Europe for its iconic pink tins, Rio Mare established the modern Italian preference for tender, oil-marinated tuna loins. The brand operates one of the largest, most technologically advanced seafood canning plants in Europe under its 'Responsible Quality' sustainability framework.
Rio Mare is found in nearly every Italian household, serving as the cultural benchmark for what everyday oil-packed tuna should taste like. Its bright pink meat has a finely calibrated moisture level that breaks apart effortlessly under a wooden spoon, making it ideal for tossing into a pan of simmering tomato, garlic, and caper sauce. The olive oil used is remarkably clear, light, and lightly seasoned with Mediterranean sea salt, integrating smoothly with pasta water to form an emulsified coating over penne or spaghetti. Unlike denser cuts of albacore that stay chunky, Rio Mare's tender grain distributes evenly across every forkful. It also works wonderfully folded into cold rice or farro salads with fresh herbs and lemon. If you prefer thick, dry steaks, its soft texture might not suit you, but for authentic pasta al tonno, nothing beats it.
Size: 5.6 oz (160 g) · Species: Skipjack / Yellowfin blend · Medium: Olive Oil · Origin: Cermenate, Italy
- Softer flake may be too delicate for those who prefer firm, steak-like cuts.
- Can be tricky to locate in standard US grocery stores, requiring specialty or online ordering.
Eater: Noted as the quintessential Italian household favorite, delivering reliable savory sweetness and effortless pasta integration.
The Strategist: Recognized by Mediterranean food enthusiasts as a vibrant, essential pantry import with dependable quality.
How Danilli chose
Testers across Epicurious, America's Test Kitchen, NYT Wirecutter, and specialty Italian food panels evaluated dozens of oil-packed tuna cans and jars side by side over multiple weeks. Evaluations included sampling the tuna plain at room temperature directly from the tin to judge moisture, salinity, and fishiness, followed by tasting the packing oil for purity and bitterness. Testers then flaked the fish into classic preparations like pasta al tonno and white bean salads to assess how well the flakes held their structural integrity without turning to mush. Danilli read the reviews and tests below and compared current prices; it does not take money from brands to pick a product.
Sources: Wirecutter · America's Test Kitchen · Epicurious · Food & Wine · The Strategist · Serious Eats
The ones Danilli skipped
Reviewers tested these too; here is why they did not make the list.
- Conservas Ortiz Bonito del Norte in Olive Oil: Hailed as a top pick by Wirecutter and Cook's Illustrated, but it is an artisanal Spanish tuna from the Basque region rather than Italian.
- Tonnino Yellowfin Tuna in Olive Oil Jar: A popular, high-scoring jarred tuna in taste tests, but produced in Costa Rica rather than following authentic Italian provenance.
- StarKist Selects E.V.O.O. Yellowfin Tuna: Widely available and inexpensive, but testers found the texture mushier and the flavor overly fishy compared to traditional Italian brands.
- Bumble Bee Prime Fillet Solid White Albacore in Water: Packed in spring water rather than olive oil, lacking the rich Mediterranean mouthfeel required for authentic Italian recipes.
- Chicken of the Sea Chunk Light Tuna in Oil: Uses cheap soybean or generic vegetable oil rather than pure olive oil, resulting in a greasy texture and dull flavor.
- As do Mar Yellowfin Tuna in Olive Oil: An outstanding Italian craft tuna, but persistently out of stock or sold at inflated third-party prices on Amazon US.
- Safe Catch Elite Wild Tuna: Excellent for strict mercury testing, but lacks an authentic Italian olive oil pack and yields a very lean, dry bite.
- Trader Joe's Yellowfin Tuna in Olive Oil: A solid budget option, but availability is restricted to physical retail stores and cannot be bought reliably on standard online storefronts.
Questions people ask
Should I drain the olive oil from Italian tuna?
No, you should keep the oil whenever possible. Premium Italian tuna steeps in olive oil for months, creating a richly flavored oil that works wonderfully as the base for salad dressings, pasta sauces, or dipping bread.
What is the difference between Italian tuna and regular canned tuna?
Standard American supermarket tuna is typically steam-cooked, shredded, and packed in spring water or vegetable oil, leaving it dry and bland. Italian tuna features whole solid loins slowly poached and packed in pure olive oil, delivering a silky texture and richer savory flavor.
How often is it safe to eat canned tuna?
The FDA recommends one to two servings of light tuna per week for most adults, or one serving of albacore tuna, due to naturally occurring trace mercury. If mercury is a primary concern, stick to skipjack or smaller yellowfin rather than larger albacore.
Is canned tuna in olive oil healthy?
Yes, it provides a nutrient-dense source of lean marine protein, selenium, vitamin D, and heart-healthy monounsaturated fats from the olive oil. Just be mindful of total fat calories if you follow a strict low-fat diet.
Updates
- 2026-11-20 Researched the current reviews and prices.
Comments
Loading…
More guides in Food & gourmet All
Danilli may earn a small commission from Amazon or the store when you buy through these buttons. The price is the same for you. Pictures marked "picture by AI" are made by Danilli's AI to show the product; check the real photos on the store page.