Sunday, November 22, 2026Sun, Nov 22Danilli Shop  ·  Sign up free
Best of Bestby Danilli
Best of Best / Food & gourmet / Peanut butter

The best peanut butter you can buy

Best of BestUpdated Nov 21, 20265 expert sources compared

Skippy Creamy takes best overall for its unmatched roasted balance, velvety spreadability, and top marks across major kitchen taste tests.

America's Test KitchenForbes VettedThe KitchnSporkedEnvironmental Working Group
The short answer
Best overall
Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter

America's Test Kitchen selected Skippy Creamy as their winning smooth peanut butter, outperforming rivals across blind spoon tastings, sandwich spreads, and cookie bake tests.

Amazon

Type: Conventional no-stir creamy · Ingredients: Roasted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oil, salt · Size: 16.3 oz jar · Storage: Room temperature

See on Amazonabout $3
Best value
Smucker's Natural Creamy Peanut Butter

Smucker's Natural Creamy Peanut Butter

Smucker's delivers a genuine two-ingredient natural peanut butter at standard grocery store prices, making it a favorite across Serious Eats and America's Test Kitchen natural brackets.

Amazon

Type: All-natural stir creamy · Ingredients: Peanuts, 1% or less of salt · Size: 16 oz glass jar · Storage: Refrigerate after stirring

See on Amazonabout $4
Cheapest that's still good
Jif Creamy Peanut Butter

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter

Jif Creamy remains the quintessential budget-friendly supermarket staple, frequently winning top honors in blind tests on Sporked and The Kitchn for its crowd-pleasing, roasty profile.

Amazon

Type: Conventional no-stir creamy · Ingredients: Roasted peanuts, sugar, contains 2% or less of molasses, fully hydrogenated vegetable oils, mono and diglycerides, salt · Size: 16 oz jar · Storage: Ro

See on Amazonabout $3
Healthiest choice
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Creamy Peanut Butter

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Creamy Peanut Butter

Certified USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified, this butter earned the top creamy ranking in The Kitchn's comprehensive peanut butter taste test.

Amazon

Type: Single-ingredient organic stir creamy · Ingredients: 100% Organic dry roasted peanuts · Size: 16 oz jar · Certifications: USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified · Storage: Refrigerate after open

See on Amazonabout $5
Upgrade pick
Koeze Cream-Nut Natural Smooth Peanut Butter

Koeze Cream-Nut Natural Smooth Peanut Butter

Featured by Forbes Vetted and specialty food editors as the ultimate gourmet peanut butter, Koeze Cream-Nut has been crafted in small batches for nearly a century.

Amazon

Type: Artisan stone-ground natural creamy · Ingredients: Virginia peanuts, sea salt · Size: 16 oz or 17 oz glass jar · Storage: Refrigerate after stirring

See on Amazonabout $11
Best crunchy
Teddie All Natural Super Chunky Peanut Butter

Teddie All Natural Super Chunky Peanut Butter

Teddie Super Chunky won top honors in crunchy taste tests from America's Test Kitchen and Forbes Vetted.

Amazon

Type: All-natural chunky stir spread · Ingredients: Dry roasted peanuts, salt · Size: 16 oz glass or plastic jar · Storage: Refrigerate after stirring

See on Amazonabout $5
D

Not sure which one?Tell Danilli what you need and it picks one of these for you. Free.

+

Free with a Danilli accountAn email when a product you saved drops in price, the Today's Deals email every morning, and 50 free credits to ask Danilli anything (guests get 3 questions). Nothing to pay.
Sign up free

What to consider

What it is

Peanut butter is an emulsion made by grinding roasted peanuts into a smooth paste or chunky spread, sometimes enhanced with salt, cane sugar, or stabilizing oils. It delivers plant-based fats, protein, and rich nutty flavor across savory and sweet dishes.

The pros

Convenient, nutrient-dense pantry staple packed with protein and healthy fats that requires no cooking and pairs easily with breads, fruits, and sauces.

The cons

Natural jars require messy stirring when opened and can separate if left at room temperature, while conventional shelf-stable jars contain small amounts of added hydrogenated oils and cane sugar.

Other options

If you want nut butter nutrition without peanuts due to allergies or dietary choices, try stone-ground almond butter or sunflower seed butter.

What matters

The choice between traditional no-stir jars and natural peanut butters defines your daily routine. Traditional varieties add tiny amounts of vegetable oil and sugar to stay perfectly emulsified at room temperature without separating. Truly natural peanut butters contain only roasted peanuts and salt, which causes peanut oil to rise to the top and requires vigorous initial stirring before refrigeration. The intensity of the nut roast matters tremendously, separating flat, bland pastes from deeply aromatic, savory spreads. Finally, texture is personal: silky smooth spreads melt on the tongue, while chunky styles range from gravelly grit to large, crunchy roasted nut pieces.

How Danilli picked

Danilli looked for these things, the same ones the testers score:

Peanut roast & flavor depth

The flavor profile relies entirely on how well the peanuts were roasted before grinding. A light or rushed roast tastes raw and vegetal, whereas an even, deep roast unlocks complex, toasty, and almost caramel-like nut flavors.

Oil stability & spreadability

How the butter handles on soft bread determines its day-to-day usability. Stabilized formulas spread like silk straight from the pantry, while unstabilized natural styles can be overly runny at first and chalky at the bottom of the jar if not mixed thoroughly.

Ingredient simplicity

A short, clean ingredient deck keeps the focus on real food quality. Natural formulas stick strictly to dry roasted peanuts and sea salt, avoiding unnecessary hydrogenated oils, palm oil, and high-fructose syrups.

Sweet-to-salty balance

Peanut butter should never taste cloying or flat. A modest pinch of salt enhances roasted aromatics, while a light touch of sugar can balance astringency without masking the peanut base.

Mouthfeel & texture

Great creamy peanut butter should dissolve smoothly without clinging like wet cement to the roof of your mouth. In chunky styles, peanut bits should remain genuinely crisp rather than soggy.

Who this is for

This guide is for anyone stocking their pantry for everyday PB&J sandwiches, post-workout spoonfuls, baking, and smooth sauces. If you want instant convenience right out of the cabinet with zero oil separation, stick to classic no-stir styles. If you prefer unrefined ingredients, zero added sugars, and pure toasted nut flavor, choose an all-natural or organic stir variety.

The picks, one by one

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter
01
Best overall

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter · about $3

America's Test Kitchen selected Skippy Creamy as their winning smooth peanut butter, outperforming rivals across blind spoon tastings, sandwich spreads, and cookie bake tests. Testers praised its ideal balance of deep roasted peanut flavor and light, almost whipped spreadability. It delivers consistent emulsification without any oil pooling.

The story behind it

Skippy was created in 1932 in Alameda, California, by Joseph Rosefield. Rosefield revolutionized peanut butter manufacturing by patenting a hydrogenation process that prevented peanut oil from separating from solids, solving the era's biggest peanut butter frustration. The brand is now manufactured by Hormel Foods in Little Rock, Arkansas. An interesting fact is that Skippy invented the crunchy peanut butter category in 1935 by blending chopped roasted peanuts into their smooth formula.

In day-to-day use, Skippy Creamy is exceptionally low-maintenance. You never have to stir it, and it keeps at room temperature in your cabinet without hardening or turning greasy. It glides across tender sandwich bread without tearing the crust, making it ideal for quick morning lunch packing. When blended into savory satay sauces or whisked into warm oatmeal, it melts uniformly without breaking. Compared to Jif, reviewers consistently note that Skippy tastes slightly lighter and less dense, dissolving immediately on the palate instead of clinging to the roof of your mouth. It also yields consistent, tender cookies that do not become oily in the oven. Skip it only if you strictly avoid refined oils and require a single-ingredient peanut butter.

Type: Conventional no-stir creamy · Ingredients: Roasted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oil, salt · Size: 16.3 oz jar · Storage: Room temperature

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Contains hydrogenated vegetable oils (cottonseed, soybean, and rapeseed) to prevent separation.
  • Includes 3 grams of added sugar per two-tablespoon serving.
What the experts found

America's Test Kitchen: Ranked as their top overall smooth peanut butter for having the most pronounced roasted peanut flavor and cleanest melt.

Forbes Vetted: Named the best creamy peanut butter overall, highlighting its light, whipped texture that never feels dense or waxy.

Smucker's Natural Creamy Peanut Butter
02
Best value

Smucker's Natural Creamy Peanut Butter · about $4

Smucker's delivers a genuine two-ingredient natural peanut butter at standard grocery store prices, making it a favorite across Serious Eats and America's Test Kitchen natural brackets. Reviewers highlight its deeply toasted, savory peanut punch accented with real salt. It provides authentic, unadulterated nut flavor without the markup charged by boutique labels.

The story behind it

The J.M. Smucker Company was founded in 1897 in Orrville, Ohio, when Jerome Monroe Smucker began selling apple butter out of the back of a horse-drawn wagon. The company expanded into fruit preserves and eventually acquired classic natural peanut butter lines, maintaining simple processing standards. Smucker's crafts this peanut butter in the United States using domestic peanuts ground fresh before packaging.

Smucker's Natural Creamy is packed in a heavy glass jar with roasted peanut oil resting at the top. When you first open the jar, you must thoroughly stir the solids from the bottom to create a cohesive paste, then store it in the refrigerator. Once chilled, it holds a thick, spreadable texture that clings generously to toast and fruit. The flavor is notably savory and salt-forward with zero added sugars, allowing the natural sweetness of roasted nuts to come forward. It makes exceptional savory dipping sauces for dumplings and spring rolls because there is no added cane sugar to throw off seasonings. If you dislike stirring jars or washing an oily butter knife, you may find the initial prep tedious, but the value-to-quality ratio is unmatched.

Type: All-natural stir creamy · Ingredients: Peanuts, 1% or less of salt · Size: 16 oz glass jar · Storage: Refrigerate after stirring

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Requires considerable initial stirring to incorporate separated natural oils.
  • Must be refrigerated after opening to maintain an even consistency.
What the experts found

America's Test Kitchen: Commended for delivering authentic natural peanut flavor with just peanuts and salt at an everyday price point.

Sporked: Praised for its rustic, homemade texture and bold, roasty-toasty profile.

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter
03
Cheapest that's still good

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter · about $3

Jif Creamy remains the quintessential budget-friendly supermarket staple, frequently winning top honors in blind tests on Sporked and The Kitchn for its crowd-pleasing, roasty profile. It offers thick, velvety texture, uniform consistency, and zero oil separation at one of the lowest per-ounce prices in retail.

The story behind it

Jif was launched in 1958 by Procter & Gamble in Cincinnati, Ohio, designed specifically to rival existing homogenized spreads with a creamier texture. In 2002, The J.M. Smucker Company acquired Jif and continues to manufacture the spread in Lexington, Kentucky, which houses one of the world's largest peanut butter production facilities. An interesting fact is that Jif's famous slogan, 'Choosy Moms Choose Jif,' became one of the most recognized advertising lines of the 20th century.

Jif is the workhorse of American family pantries. Day to day, its signature feature is density: it is a touch thicker and richer than Skippy, forming hefty, satisfying spreads that stay put on bread. It incorporates a tiny touch of molasses alongside regular sugar, giving it an amber hue and a faint caramel finish that pairs well with tart jams like raspberry or blackberry. The screw-top plastic jar is shatterproof and safe for kids making their own snacks. Cleanup is simple, and the butter never hardens or weeps oil even when stored in a warm kitchen. Skip this pick if you dislike sweetened spreads or want to avoid hydrogenated palm and rapeseed oils.

Type: Conventional no-stir creamy · Ingredients: Roasted peanuts, sugar, contains 2% or less of molasses, fully hydrogenated vegetable oils, mono and diglycerides, salt · Size: 16 oz jar · Storage: Ro

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Thicker consistency can feel slightly heavy on the palate compared to whipped spreads.
  • Includes added molasses, refined sugar, and hydrogenated oils.
What the experts found

Sporked: Named the best overall grocery peanut butter, praising its sweet-salty evolution and unbeatable everyday accessibility.

The Kitchn: Crowned the best no-stir creamy peanut butter for baking and thick everyday spreading.

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
04
Healthiest choice

365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Creamy Peanut Butter · about $5

Certified USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified, this butter earned the top creamy ranking in The Kitchn's comprehensive peanut butter taste test. With an ingredient deck containing literally one item—organic dry roasted peanuts—it is naturally free of added sugars, sodium, hydrogenated oils, palm oil, and synthetic preservatives while scoring top marks from EWG Food Scores.

The story behind it

Whole Foods Market introduced the 365 brand in 1997 in Austin, Texas, aiming to make certified organic groceries affordable and widely accessible. The peanut butter is produced in the United States from certified organic peanuts grown without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers. An interesting fact is that the brand adheres to Whole Foods Market's strict quality standards, which ban over 300 common food additives, artificial preservatives, and hydrogenated fats across all products.

Despite having zero added sugar and zero added salt, testers across food panels were amazed by how sweet and nutty this spread tastes on its own. The gentle dry roasting process concentrates the natural sugars present in organic peanuts, preventing the bland, pasty flavor found in lesser single-ingredient brands. In daily use, it pours in a smooth, viscous ribbon once stirred, making it exceptionally easy to drizzle over warm steel-cut oats, acai bowls, or sliced bananas. Because there are no hydrogenated fats, you will see a natural layer of peanut oil when you unseal the jar. Storing the jar upside down in your pantry for a day before opening makes stirring much easier, and keeping it in the fridge afterward locks in the creamy texture. Skip this pick if you crave a heavily salted, stiff peanut butter.

Type: Single-ingredient organic stir creamy · Ingredients: 100% Organic dry roasted peanuts · Size: 16 oz jar · Certifications: USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified · Storage: Refrigerate after open

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Contains zero added salt, which may taste under-seasoned to those accustomed to salted butters.
  • Thinner, pourable consistency can soak into light, porous sandwich bread if not chilled.
What the experts found

The Kitchn: Awarded best creamy peanut butter overall, calling its pure single-ingredient flavor remarkably sweet, nutty, and decadent.

Environmental Working Group (EWG): Receives top food scores for organic certification, minimal processing, and complete absence of additives.

Koeze Cream-Nut Natural Smooth Peanut Butter
05
Upgrade pick

Koeze Cream-Nut Natural Smooth Peanut Butter · about $11

Featured by Forbes Vetted and specialty food editors as the ultimate gourmet peanut butter, Koeze Cream-Nut has been crafted in small batches for nearly a century. Made with only top-grade Virginia peanuts and sea salt, it delivers an intensely concentrated, unctuous roasted peanut flavor that mass-market brands cannot replicate.

The story behind it

Koeze Company was founded in 1910 by Sibbele Koeze in Grand Rapids, Michigan, starting as a local wholesale produce distributor. In 1925, the family began manufacturing Cream-Nut peanut butter using vintage equipment and heritage Virginia peanuts, a process they still follow in Michigan today. A charming fact about Koeze is that they still utilize vintage roasters and stone mills from the early 20th century to achieve their signature texture.

Eating Koeze Cream-Nut is a dramatically different culinary experience than scooping a standard grocery jar. Koeze uses premium Virginia peanuts, which are larger, naturally sweeter, and have a higher oil content than common runner peanuts. They slow-roast the nuts in vintage gas-fired roasters before grinding them on antique millstones. The resulting texture is extraordinarily rich, buttery, and thick, with a silky mouthfeel that dissolves slowly. It comes packaged in an embossed glass jar that looks gorgeous on the breakfast table. It does separate naturally, requiring a quick stir with a sturdy knife before placing it in the refrigerator. It commands a premium price, but for eating off a spoon, entertaining, or making luxury confections, nothing matches it.

Type: Artisan stone-ground natural creamy · Ingredients: Virginia peanuts, sea salt · Size: 16 oz or 17 oz glass jar · Storage: Refrigerate after stirring

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Significantly more expensive per ounce than supermarket brands.
  • Dense consistency when chilled requires warming slightly before spreading on soft bread.
What the experts found

Forbes Vetted: Named the best gourmet peanut butter for its unctuous, pure roasted Virginia peanut intensity.

Teddie All Natural Super Chunky Peanut Butter
06
Best crunchy

Teddie All Natural Super Chunky Peanut Butter · about $5

Teddie Super Chunky won top honors in crunchy taste tests from America's Test Kitchen and Forbes Vetted. It is celebrated for its sheer volume of crunchy roasted peanut pieces suspended in a rich, two-ingredient base made only of dry roasted peanuts and salt.

The story behind it

The Leavitt Corporation was founded by Michael Leavitt in 1925 in Boston, Massachusetts, roasting nuts for local street vendors. The company created the Teddie brand in 1930 and continues to operate out of Everett, Massachusetts, as a family-owned enterprise. An interesting fact is that Teddie supplies peanut butter to food banks across the Northeast and still operates under its founding family's third-generation leadership.

If you find most commercial crunchy peanut butters underwhelming due to soft or sparse nut fragments, Teddie is the definitive remedy. Every spoonful is densely packed with hearty, distinct chunks of dry-roasted peanuts that provide a loud, crisp crunch. The surrounding butter has a lightly rustic, stone-ground graininess that feels substantial and authentic. Because it contains no added vegetable shortenings, you will need to stir the jar upon delivery, but the high density of peanuts makes the oil reincorporate faster than in loose, watery natural butters. Once chilled, it holds together firmly, making it ideal for slathering on crisp celery sticks or spreading across warm whole-grain toast where the peanut pieces lightly toast against the warm bread. Skip it if you want an effortless no-stir sandwich butter for fragile white bread.

Type: All-natural chunky stir spread · Ingredients: Dry roasted peanuts, salt · Size: 16 oz glass or plastic jar · Storage: Refrigerate after stirring

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • The abundance of heavy peanut chunks makes spreading on soft sandwich bread difficult.
  • Natural oil separation requires initial stirring upon opening.
What the experts found

America's Test Kitchen: Ranked among the top crunchy natural peanut butters for its remarkable volume of real roasted peanut chunks.

Forbes Vetted: Named the best crunchy peanut butter, praising its mid-sized peanut bits suspended in a richly textured base.

How Danilli chose

Professional food testers at America's Test Kitchen, The Kitchn, Sporked, and Forbes evaluated dozens of jars side by side over several weeks. Testers evaluated spreads straight from a spoon, smeared across soft white sandwich bread, and paired with apples and crackers to test adherence and mouthfeel. They also measured emulsification stability, oil separation rates, and baking performance in peanut butter cookies. Danilli read the reviews and tests below and compared current prices; it does not take money from brands to pick a product.

Sources: America's Test Kitchen · Forbes Vetted · The Kitchn · Sporked · Environmental Working Group

The ones Danilli skipped

Reviewers tested these too; here is why they did not make the list.

  • Peter Pan Creamy Peanut Butter: Ranked near the bottom in taste tests by Forbes and America's Test Kitchen due to an artificial, muddy flavor and pasty texture.
  • Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Dark Roasted: Testers found the aggressive dark roast tasted burnt and harsh, leaving a dry, sandy mouthfeel.
  • Crazy Richard's Crunchy Peanut Butter: Downgraded in Forbes and Cook's evaluations for an oily, watery consistency that made mixing frustrating and muted the nut flavor.
  • Justin's Classic Peanut Butter: Testers noted a surprisingly dry, sticky mouthfeel that clung uncomfortably to the mouth despite the brand's premium price.
  • Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Spread: Overwhelmed with added sugars and emulsifiers, making it taste more like candy confection than real roasted peanuts.
  • Skippy Reduced Fat Creamy: While better than other low-fat brands, substituting fat with corn syrup solids leads to an overly gummy and processed texture.
  • Pic's Smooth Peanut Butter: Criticized in blind tastings for a pasty, chalky mouthfeel and a distracting bitter citrus pith undertone.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between natural and regular peanut butter?

Regular peanut butter contains small amounts of hydrogenated vegetable oil and sugar, keeping it permanently smooth, emulsified, and shelf-stable without stirring. Natural peanut butter consists purely of roasted peanuts and salt, which naturally separates into oil and solid layers and needs stirring and refrigeration.

What is the best way to stir natural peanut butter?

Store the unopened jar upside down in your pantry for a day or two so the rising oil travels through the solids. When opening, insert a sturdy butter knife or fork down to the bottom, stir in slow circles until cohesive, and place the jar in the refrigerator to keep it from separating again.

Does peanut butter need to be refrigerated?

Conventional no-stir peanut butters like Skippy and Jif do not need refrigeration and will stay fresh at room temperature for months. Truly natural peanut butters without added stabilizers should be refrigerated after stirring to prevent the oil from separating and to stop the natural oils from turning rancid.

Why is palm oil added to some peanut butters?

Palm oil is naturally solid at room temperature, allowing manufacturers to create a 'no-stir natural' peanut butter without using chemically hydrogenated oils. However, many testers find palm oil creates a slightly waxy film on the tongue compared to pure peanut oil or traditional recipes.

Updates

  • 2026-11-21 Researched the current reviews and prices.

Comments

Loading…

Sign in free to comment.

Danilli may earn a small commission from Amazon or the store when you buy through these buttons. The price is the same for you. Pictures marked "picture by AI" are made by Danilli's AI to show the product; check the real photos on the store page.

Danilli Best of Best, by Danilli Inc. · Miami

Danilli · Danilli Shop · All Best of Best guides · Terms · Privacy

© 2026 Danilli Inc.