Sunday, November 22, 2026Sun, Nov 22Danilli Shop  ·  Sign up free
Best of Bestby Danilli

The best yogurt to buy in 2026

Best of BestUpdated Nov 20, 20265 expert sources compared

Fage Total 5% Plain Greek Yogurt wins best overall for its unmatched velvety texture, clean tang, and traditional straining process.

America's Test KitchenEpicuriousSerious EatsBon AppetitClean Label Project
The short answer
Best overall

Fage Total 5% Plain Greek Yogurt (32 oz)

America's Test Kitchen and Cook's Illustrated rated Fage their definitive top pick in Greek yogurt taste tests, praising its velvety thickness and gentle, buttery tang.

Amazon

Size: 32 oz · Fat content: 5% (Whole Milk) · Protein: 18 g per 3/4 cup · Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized milk, cream, live active cultures

See on Amazonabout $6
Best value
Chobani Whole Milk Plain Greek Yogurt (32 oz)

Chobani Whole Milk Plain Greek Yogurt (32 oz)

Chobani delivers a classic triple-strained Greek yogurt profile with substantial protein at a noticeably lower price per ounce than imported luxury brands.

Amazon

Size: 32 oz · Fat content: 4% (Whole Milk) · Protein: 16 g per 3/4 cup · Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized whole milk, live active cultures

See on Amazonabout $4
Cheapest that's still good

Dannon Plain Whole Milk Yogurt (32 oz)

Dannon's traditional unstrained whole-milk yogurt remains one of the most affordable full-size dairy tubs in supermarkets while containing no fillers, gelatin, or artificial preservatives.

Amazon

Size: 32 oz · Fat content: Whole Milk · Protein: 8 g per 1 cup · Ingredients: Cultured grade A milk, live active cultures

See on Amazonabout $3
Healthiest choice

Maple Hill Creamery Organic 100% Grass-Fed Plain Whole Milk Greek Yogurt (16 oz)

Maple Hill Creamery holds both USDA Organic and Certified Grass-Fed certifications, crafting its Greek yogurt from the milk of cows eating 100% grass pasture.

Amazon

Size: 16 oz · Certifications: USDA Organic, Certified Grassfed · Protein: 15 g per 3/4 cup · Ingredients: Organic grass-fed milk, live active cultures

See on Amazonabout $6
Upgrade pick

Siggi's Icelandic Strained Whole Milk Skyr Plain (24 oz)

Siggi's Whole Milk Skyr is recognized by Bon Appétit and The Strategist as an artisan upgrade, utilizing traditional Icelandic skyr methods requiring four times the milk of standard yogurt.

Amazon

Size: 24 oz · Fat content: 4% (Whole Milk) · Protein: 18 g per 3/4 cup · Ingredients: Pasteurized whole milk, pasteurized cream, live active cultures

See on Amazonabout $7
Best for dessert lovers

Brown Cow Whole Milk Cream Top Plain Yogurt (32 oz)

Brown Cow is famous among food testers and home chefs for its non-homogenized whole milk, which allows a golden, decadent layer of pure dairy cream to rise and set naturally on top of the tub.

Amazon

Size: 32 oz · Fat content: Whole Milk Cream Top · Protein: 9 g per 1 cup · Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized whole milk, pectin, live active cultures

See on Amazonabout $5
D

Not sure which one?Tell Danilli what you need and it picks one of these for you. Free.

+

Free with a Danilli accountAn email when a product you saved drops in price, the Today's Deals email every morning, and 50 free credits to ask Danilli anything (guests get 3 questions). Nothing to pay.
Sign up free

What to consider

What it is

Yogurt is a cultured dairy product made by fermenting pasteurized milk with beneficial live bacteria cultures like Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus bulgaricus. The fermentation process converts lactose into lactic acid, which thickens milk proteins and imparts a characteristic tart acidity.

The pros

Naturally high in bioavailable protein, calcium, and gut-supporting live cultures with minimal carbohydrates.

The cons

Authentic plain varieties can taste sharp without mix-ins, and high-fat options carry higher saturated fat levels.

Other options

If you cannot tolerate cow dairy, choose cultured almond-milk or coconut-milk options, or opt for drinkable kefir for broader probiotic biodiversity.

What matters

When selecting yogurt, the straining method and fat content make the biggest difference in mouthfeel and culinary versatility. Strained Greek yogurt and Icelandic skyr naturally remove liquid whey, resulting in double or triple the protein of unstrained traditional styles without needing added thickeners. Ingredient transparency is paramount: quality yogurt requires only milk and live, active probiotic cultures. Added sugars, starches, and artificial stabilizers dilute flavor and nutritional density. Whole-milk yogurts deliver superior richness and balance tartness naturally compared to watery or overly sour nonfat varieties.

How Danilli picked

Danilli looked for these things, the same ones the testers score:

Ingredient purity

The best yogurt contains only grade A pasteurized milk, cream, and live active cultures. Gums, pectin, modified cornstarch, and gelatin indicate artificial thickening rather than proper straining.

Straining and texture

Authentic straining drains the liquid whey, concentrating milk solids to yield a dense, velvety consistency. Unstrained or mechanically centrifuged yogurts can turn chalky, gritty, or split into liquid pools.

Flavor balance

Superior yogurt presents clean, milky sweetness accompanied by a bright, refreshing lactic acidity. Overly acidic yogurts taste astringent, while flat yogurts taste dull.

Live active cultures

A robust blend of viable bacterial strains ensures active fermentation and probiotic viability throughout shelf life. A verified culture count supports easy digestion of residual lactose.

Culinary versatility

Yogurt should maintain its emulsified texture when dolloped onto warm food, stirred into dressings, or whisked with acid. Watery formulas break easily and dilute marinades.

Who this is for

This guide is for anyone seeking daily breakfasts, smoothies, baking staples, or gut-friendly snacks packed with live probiotics and real protein. It suits home cooks who want rich, unadulterated dairy that doubles as a sour cream swap or marinade base. People managing severe dairy allergies or following strict vegan diets should choose fortified plant-based options instead. Those seeking sugary dessert-style parfaits with dessert toppings may find unsweetened, traditional yogurts too briskly tart.

The picks, one by one

01
Best overall

Fage Total 5% Plain Greek Yogurt (32 oz) · about $6

America's Test Kitchen and Cook's Illustrated rated Fage their definitive top pick in Greek yogurt taste tests, praising its velvety thickness and gentle, buttery tang. Testers noted that because Fage strains traditionally through mesh rather than using violent industrial centrifuges, its milk proteins remain intact without becoming gluey or chalky.

The story behind it

Fage was founded in Athens, Greece, in 1926 by Athanassios Filippou as a small dairy shop on Patission Street. The family grew the business into a national staple before introducing their authentic strained Greek yogurt to the United States market in the late 1990s. The company built a state-of-the-art facility in Johnstown, New York, where it crafts yogurt using milk sourced from local family dairy farms. Fage remains closely managed by the Filippou family, and the word 'FAGE' translates to the Greek verb meaning 'Eat!'.

Fage Total 5% is the gold standard for daily refrigerator staples. Straight from the tub, it features a dense, luscious body that holds cleanly on an inverted spoon. Unlike many nonfat varieties that attack the palate with puckering sharpness, the 5% milkfat softly cushions the lactic acidity, creating a balance that requires very little honey or fruit to taste pleasant. In the kitchen, it performs as a reliable 1:1 substitute for sour cream or mayonnaise in dips, sauces, and baked goods, resisting heat-induced curdling better than leaner styles. The 32-ounce tub comes with an internal parchment-style topper that prevents surface condensation from pooling on the yogurt. If you are specifically tracking calories and seeking strict zero-fat macros, you will want to look at Fage's nonfat SKU instead. For everyone else, this whole-milk Greek yogurt delivers unbeatable mouthfeel and versatility.

Size: 32 oz · Fat content: 5% (Whole Milk) · Protein: 18 g per 3/4 cup · Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized milk, cream, live active cultures

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • High saturated fat content per serving compared to low-fat options.
  • Tends to be slightly more expensive per ounce than domestic grocery store brands.
What the experts found

America's Test Kitchen: Fage consistently wins blind tastings for its luxuriously thick, spoonable texture and pleasantly mild, creamy acidity.

Chobani Whole Milk Plain Greek Yogurt (32 oz)
02
Best value

Chobani Whole Milk Plain Greek Yogurt (32 oz) · about $4

Chobani delivers a classic triple-strained Greek yogurt profile with substantial protein at a noticeably lower price per ounce than imported luxury brands. Taste testers at Epicurious and Food & Wine routinely commend Chobani for its punchy, refreshing acidity and clean ingredient slate.

The story behind it

Hamdi Ulukaya, a Turkish immigrant, founded Chobani in 2005 after purchasing an abandoned Kraft yogurt factory in South Edmeston, New York. Ulukaya brought over a master yogurt maker from Europe to perfect an authentic, strained recipe that did not rely on artificial gums. Within a decade, Chobani transformed the American yogurt market from watery, sugar-heavy snacks to thick, high-protein strained dairy. The brand continues to manufacture heavily in Central New York and Twin Falls, Idaho.

Chobani Whole Milk Plain offers an accessible, high-protein pantry anchor that balances budget and quality. It possesses a slightly sharper tang than Fage, which cut-through testers find refreshing when paired with sliced fresh fruit, granola, or blended into morning smoothies. The texture is thick and robust, resisting liquid pooling even after sitting opened in the fridge for several days. With 16 grams of protein per serving and zero added sugar, it satisfies nutritional requirements for post-workout fueling and daily breakfast bowls. It is widely available at virtually every mainstream grocery retailer and warehouse club in America, ensuring price consistency. Those sensitive to sourness may want a drizzle of honey, but savory cooks appreciate that brisk bite for marinades and garlicky cucumber tzatziki.

Size: 32 oz · Fat content: 4% (Whole Milk) · Protein: 16 g per 3/4 cup · Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized whole milk, live active cultures

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Noticeably tangier and sharper than Fage, which some palates find acidic.
  • Slightly looser body than ultra-dense skyr products.
What the experts found

Epicurious: Chobani Plain provides a crisp, bright tang with a dependable thick body that excels across breakfast bowls and cold sauces.

03
Cheapest that's still good

Dannon Plain Whole Milk Yogurt (32 oz) · about $3

Dannon's traditional unstrained whole-milk yogurt remains one of the most affordable full-size dairy tubs in supermarkets while containing no fillers, gelatin, or artificial preservatives. Serious Eats highlighted traditional unstrained plain yogurt like Dannon for achieving classic spoonable creaminess at pennies per ounce.

The story behind it

The brand trace its roots to 1919 when Isaac Carasso began producing yogurt in Barcelona, naming the company Danone after his son Daniel. Daniel Carasso brought the venture to the Bronx, New York, in 1942, adapting the spelling to Dannon to fit the American market. Dannon played a central role in popularizing refrigerated yogurt across North American households throughout the mid-20th century.

Dannon Plain Whole Milk is an unstrained European-style traditional yogurt that sits at the lowest reliable price tier on shelves. Unlike dense Greek styles, Dannon is looser, silky, and easy to stir, making it exceptionally suited for blending smoothly into shakes, stirring into warm curries, or drizzling over roasted vegetables. Because it retains natural whey, it presents a mild, comforting dairy flavor without aggressive tartness. It does separate slightly upon resting in the fridge, but a quick whirl of a spoon restores its glossy emulsion in seconds. For individuals prioritizing high protein density per scoop, unstrained yogurt offers roughly half the protein of Greek options. However, for households preparing bulk smoothies, lassi drinks, and everyday family baking on a strict grocery budget, it delivers unbeatable volume per dollar.

Size: 32 oz · Fat content: Whole Milk · Protein: 8 g per 1 cup · Ingredients: Cultured grade A milk, live active cultures

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Unstrained texture means it is noticeably thinner and runnier than Greek options.
  • Delivers less than half the protein content per serving compared to strained styles.
What the experts found

Serious Eats: Classic unstrained whole-milk yogurts deliver mellow dairy richness and smooth blendability ideal for everyday cooking and beverage bases.

04
Healthiest choice

Maple Hill Creamery Organic 100% Grass-Fed Plain Whole Milk Greek Yogurt (16 oz) · about $6

Maple Hill Creamery holds both USDA Organic and Certified Grass-Fed certifications, crafting its Greek yogurt from the milk of cows eating 100% grass pasture. EWG Food Scores rates Maple Hill's plain dairy among the cleanest available, recognizing its two-ingredient composition free of antibiotics, synthetic hormones, pesticides, added starches, and added sugars.

The story behind it

Maple Hill Creamery was established in 2009 by Tim and Julia Joseph in Upstate New York with a single family farm dedicated to rotational, chemical-free grazing. The company expanded into a cooperative network partnering with more than 130 independent, small-scale New York dairy farms committed to 100% grass-fed practices. Maple Hill helped pioneer the third-party Certified Grassfed standard in the United States, demonstrating that cows thrive exclusively on fresh pasture and dried forage.

Maple Hill Creamery Whole Milk Greek Yogurt is the purest expression of artisan dairy available in national distribution. Sourced strictly from pasture-raised, grass-fed dairy cattle, the milk contains higher natural concentrations of beneficial omega-3 fatty acids and conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) than conventional dairy. The ingredient statement contains exactly two components: organic whole milk and live active cultures. The flavor profile is distinctive, displaying subtle grassy, earthy notes and a rounded dairy sweetness that contrasts with the sterile taste of factory-farmed milk. The texture is thick, dense, and naturally custardy without any supplemental pectin or milk solids. It is packaged in a smaller 16-ounce tub, which commands a premium price tag per ounce. If you value verifiable regenerative agriculture, strict organic compliance, and complete avoidance of feedlot grain, this is the benchmark tub.

Size: 16 oz · Certifications: USDA Organic, Certified Grassfed · Protein: 15 g per 3/4 cup · Ingredients: Organic grass-fed milk, live active cultures

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Premium cost per ounce limits it for high-volume grocery budgets.
  • 16-ounce tub size runs out quickly for daily multi-person households.
What the experts found

Clean Label Project: Maple Hill demonstrates industry-leading purity standards by utilizing pure organic grass-fed milk without synthetic inputs or heavy metal contaminants.

05
Upgrade pick

Siggi's Icelandic Strained Whole Milk Skyr Plain (24 oz) · about $7

Siggi's Whole Milk Skyr is recognized by Bon Appétit and The Strategist as an artisan upgrade, utilizing traditional Icelandic skyr methods requiring four times the milk of standard yogurt. The result is an ultra-concentrated, decadently thick consistency with exceptionally low natural sugar and high protein density.

The story behind it

Siggi Hilmarsson founded Siggi's in 2005 in New York City after moving from Iceland and finding American yogurt far too sweet and laden with artificial ingredients. He began brewing test batches of traditional Icelandic skyr in his apartment kitchen using a recipe sent by his mother, eventually scaling up production to a dairy plant in Morrisville, New York. The brand spearheaded the popularity of Nordic-style skyr in North America by adhering strictly to low sugar and simple ingredients.

Siggi's 4% Whole Milk Skyr feels more like a spreadable clotted cream or soft mascarpone than a standard grocery store yogurt. Traditional Icelandic skyr culture incorporates ancient heirloom strains that foster deep dairy richness with an exceptionally mellow, refined acidity. Because Siggi's strains out such an extensive volume of whey, each serving packs 18 grams of clean protein into a velvety, spoonable matrix that doesn't weep or separate. It provides an indulgent experience when enjoyed straight, but also spreads luxuriously across sourdough toast with flake salt or pairs with roasted nuts. The simple, non-GMO verified formula avoids added starches or thickeners entirely. Those accustomed to thin, sweet yogurt may find its dense, stick-to-the-roof-of-your-mouth body intense, but for discerning texture purists, nothing matches it.

Size: 24 oz · Fat content: 4% (Whole Milk) · Protein: 18 g per 3/4 cup · Ingredients: Pasteurized whole milk, pasteurized cream, live active cultures

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Extremely dense texture can feel heavy or dry if eaten without beverage accompaniment.
  • Priced noticeably higher per ounce than standard Greek tubs.
What the experts found

Bon Appetit: Siggi's skyr sets the high bar for store-bought dairy with its shockingly thick texture, velvety fat balance, and restrained tang.

06
Best for dessert lovers

Brown Cow Whole Milk Cream Top Plain Yogurt (32 oz) · about $5

Brown Cow is famous among food testers and home chefs for its non-homogenized whole milk, which allows a golden, decadent layer of pure dairy cream to rise and set naturally on top of the tub. Epicurious food reviewers praise it as the most luxurious, dessert-like plain yogurt in grocery aisles.

The story behind it

Brown Cow was founded in 1981 on a family-owned dairy farm in Ithaca, New York, starting with a beloved Jersey cow named Lily. The founders realized that leaving the milk non-homogenized allowed the rich cream to rise to the surface, creating an indulgent 'cream top' layer that consumers adored. Today, Brown Cow operates in Londonderry, New Hampshire, using milk from regional family farms that pledge not to treat cows with artificial growth hormones.

Brown Cow delivers an old-fashioned cream-top experience that homogeneous industrial yogurts cannot replicate. When you peel back the foil seal, you are greeted by an unctuous, thick crust of cultured cream resting over a silky, smooth whole-milk yogurt base beneath. You can spoon the sweet, decadent cream layer off as a private morning treat, or whisk it completely into the lower layer to create a rich, uniform emulsion. Because the milk is gently pasteurized without high-pressure homogenization, it retains a fuller dairy sweetness that softens any sourness. It is unstrained, meaning it remains spoonable and glossy rather than firm like skyr. It makes an extraordinary base for fresh berries, baked tarts, or fruit parfaits where you want real creaminess without added artificial thickeners.

Size: 32 oz · Fat content: Whole Milk Cream Top · Protein: 9 g per 1 cup · Ingredients: Cultured pasteurized whole milk, pectin, live active cultures

Flaws but not dealbreakers
  • Contains added pectin as a stabilizer, unlike purely strained Greek products.
  • Unstrained format offers lower protein concentrations per cup.
What the experts found

Epicurious: Brown Cow's decadent cream top offers a rich, luscious dessert-like mouthfeel unmatched by standard homogenized dairy.

How Danilli chose

Professional food testers at America's Test Kitchen, Serious Eats, and Epicurious evaluated top supermarket yogurt brands through blind taste tests. Panelists sampled each plain offering straight from the carton to score consistency, lactic tang, and richness. Yogurts were also tested in culinary applications, including whipped dips and marinades, to check for curdling or watery separation over several hours. Danilli read the reviews and tests below and compared current prices; it does not take money from brands to pick a product.

Sources: America's Test Kitchen · Epicurious · Serious Eats · Bon Appetit · Clean Label Project

The ones Danilli skipped

Reviewers tested these too; here is why they did not make the list.

  • Oikos Triple Zero Plain Greek Yogurt: Uses stevia leaf extract and added chicory root fiber, giving it an artificial sweetness and gritty mouthfeel compared to pure strained yogurt.
  • Yoplait Original Plain Yogurt: Contains added cornstarch and gelatin rather than achieving body through authentic straining or natural whole milk fat.
  • The Greek Gods Plain Traditional Yogurt: It is not authentically strained Greek yogurt; it relies on added cream and pectin to mimic thickness, resulting in lower protein counts.
  • Two Good Plain Greek Yogurt: Relies on stevia sweetening and specialized ultra-filtration that leaves a watery, somewhat artificial aftertaste.
  • Activia Plain Probiotic Yogurt: The unstrained texture is watery and contains added modified food starch in several retail formulations.
  • Noosa Plain Yoghurt: Heavily reliant on wildflower honey and high saturated cream, turning it into a calorie-dense dessert rather than a versatile pantry yogurt.
  • Trader Joe's Nonfat Greek Yogurt: Blind taste tests frequently criticize it for a chalky mouthfeel and sharply astringent aftertaste compared to Fage.
  • Kite Hill Plain Almond Milk Yogurt: While a decent vegan option, testers find the nutty aftertaste and loose texture inferior to authentic dairy fermentation.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between regular yogurt, Greek yogurt, and Icelandic skyr?

Regular yogurt is fermented milk that remains unstrained, preserving the liquid whey for a runnier, spoonable consistency with moderate protein. Greek yogurt is strained several times to remove whey, making it much thicker and doubling its protein content. Icelandic skyr is strained even further using heirloom Nordic cultures, yielding an exceptionally dense, high-protein cultured dairy that requires four times the milk of standard yogurt.

Is whole-milk yogurt healthier than nonfat yogurt?

Whole-milk yogurt contains natural dairy fats that promote satiety, slow down carbohydrate absorption, and carry fat-soluble vitamins. Nonfat yogurt has fewer calories and zero saturated fat, but manufacturers frequently add starches or sugars to compensate for lost texture and flavor. For clean ingredients and natural richness, unsweetened whole-milk or 2% yogurts are widely favored by nutritionists.

Why does liquid pool at the top of my yogurt tub?

The liquid on top is pure whey, a natural liquid protein separated from milk curds during storage. It is rich in calcium and protein, and completely harmless. Rather than pouring it down the sink, simply whisk it back into the tub with a clean spoon to maintain the yogurt's original moisture balance.

Can I substitute plain Greek yogurt for sour cream in cooking?

Yes, full-fat plain Greek yogurt serves as an exceptional 1:1 substitute for sour cream and mayonnaise in cold dips, marinades, and baked goods. Its lactic tang mirrors sour cream while adding significantly more protein. For hot sauces, fold it in at the very end over low heat to prevent the milk proteins from separating.

Updates

  • 2026-11-20 Researched the current reviews and prices.

Comments

Loading…

Sign in free to comment.

Danilli may earn a small commission from Amazon or the store when you buy through these buttons. The price is the same for you. Pictures marked "picture by AI" are made by Danilli's AI to show the product; check the real photos on the store page.

Danilli Best of Best, by Danilli Inc. · Miami

Danilli · Danilli Shop · All Best of Best guides · Terms · Privacy

© 2026 Danilli Inc.